Get 5% of discount using the code
MYESIMNOW5
close-icon-modal
Buy eSIM
Trustpilot

Skip Nassau this Thanksgiving: 7 Quiet Bahamas islands where the beach is still empty

Discover a quieter side of the Bahamas this Thanksgiving. From Harbour Island to Bimini, explore 7 Out Islands with beautiful beaches and fewer crowds.

Published: November 17, 2026

Plenty of US travelers swap the turkey for the tropics and fly to the Bahamas for Thanksgiving week, but most end up in the same two places: Nassau and Paradise Island.

What many don’t realize is that the Bahamas actually has 16 island destinations, and most visitors never see beyond those two.

That’s why one person’s Bahamas getaway could consist of crowded airports, busy cruise ports, and lines along Nassau’s waterfront, while another person could be strolling along a secluded pink sand beach and exploring sleepy fishing villages.

If you want a tropical break that actually feels peaceful this Thanksgiving, we’ve rounded up seven quieter islands.

We’re also sharing how to get there from the US, because you might be surprised to learn that many have nonstop flights from US cities.

IslandGetting there from the USGood for
EleutheraNonstop from Miami, Atlanta, Fort LauderdaleRoad trips, wild beaches
Harbour IslandFly to North Eleuthera, then a 5-minute ferryCouples, pink sand
The AbacosNonstop to Marsh Harbour, then a ferrySailing, island hopping
Little ExumaNonstop to Exuma from Miami or AtlantaCalm beaches
Long IslandNo direct flights Thanksgiving week (Nov 23 to 28); connect via NassauDivers, total quiet
Cat IslandSmall-airline flights from Fort Lauderdale (limited seats)Hikers, culture
Bimini25-minute seaplane from Fort LauderdaleA long weekend

1. Eleuthera: A long, thin island built for a Thanksgiving road trip

Best for: Travelers who want to rent a car and stop wherever the beach looks empty.

Stretching 110 miles from end to end, the long, thin island of Eleuthera is made for exploring at your own pace.

With 210 miles of coastline, including more than 35 miles of pink-sand beaches, finding a quiet spot to spread your towel shouldn’t be difficult.

The island’s most famous landmark is the Glass Window Bridge on Queen’s Highway. Here, you’ll find a narrow strip of land separating the deep Atlantic from the calmer turquoise waters of the Bight of Eleuthera, creating a striking contrast of dark blue and light turquoise.

Aerial view of the Glass Window Bridge on Eleuthera, with the dark blue Atlantic on one side and turquoise shallows on the other
On Eleuthera’s Queen’s Highway, only a narrow strip of rock separates the deep-blue Atlantic from the turquoise Bight of Eleuthera.

Getting to Eleuthera is surprisingly easy, as three US airlines fly direct to North Eleuthera Airport. American Airlines flies from Miami, Delta flies from Atlanta on select days, and Tradewind flies daily from Fort Lauderdale.

2. Harbour Island: Pink sand and clapboard houses, five minutes across the water

Best for: Couples who want a slow, romantic Thanksgiving week.

Known affectionately as “Briland” by the locals, Harbour Island is a former Bahamian capital with a laid-back charm that’s hard to leave.

Pink Sands Beach is a must-visit. This beautiful stretch of blush-colored shoreline is perfect for sunrise or sunset walks, when the sand’s color looks most vibrant.

Also make a point of going inland to see Dunmore Town’s pastel New England-style clapboard cottages, which date back to Loyalist settlers in the late 1700s.

You can reach Harbour Island only by boat, but the journey takes just five minutes by ferry from North Eleuthera.

3. The Abacos: Hope Town and the last kerosene lighthouse

Best for: History lovers, boating enthusiasts, and island hoppers.

Stretching 120 miles across a chain of islands and cays, The Abacos are known as the boating capital of the Bahamas.

One of the highlights is Hope Town on Elbow Cay, home to the candy-striped Elbow Reef Lighthouse, the world’s last working kerosene-burning lighthouse. To reach it, you’ll need to take a ferry from Marsh Harbour.

There’s plenty more to explore, too, including the charming Green Turtle Cay, famous for its New England-style architecture and being the birthplace of the Goombay Smash cocktail.

The primary airport serving The Abacos is Marsh Harbour. American Airlines flies there from Miami, Delta from Atlanta, and Tradewind from Fort Lauderdale.

4. Little Exuma: The quiet side of the Exumas

Best for: Travelers who want peace and seclusion.

Little Exuma offers a slower-paced alternative to the busier parts of the Bahamas as well as other popular Thanksgiving destinations like Cancun and Punta Cana.

Connected to Great Exuma by a small bridge, this quiet island is home to Tropic of Cancer Beach, a beautiful stretch of white sand and turquoise water.

Aerial view of Tropic of Cancer Beach on Little Exuma with white sand and bright turquoise water
Tropic of Cancer Beach on Little Exuma is a long stretch of white sand and turquoise water with plenty of room to yourself.

For even more seclusion, you can take a water taxi from George Town to the tiny Stocking Island, where you’ll find peaceful beaches, crystal-clear waters, and excellent snorkeling spots.

Getting to Little Exuma is straightforward: fly into Exuma International Airport near George Town, then drive south across the bridge. Delta flies there from Atlanta on select days, and American Airlines flies nonstop from Miami. American also steps up to three daily flights from December 17, ahead of the peak winter season in the Bahamas.

5. Long Island: Cliffs, calm beaches, and a blue hole 663 feet deep

Best for: Divers, anglers, and travelers seeking genuine solitude.

Long Island offers a Thanksgiving escape that feels a world away from the crowds, with a mix of dramatic scenery and miles of untouched beaches. The east coast is lined with rugged Atlantic cliffs, while the west has calm, swimmable beaches.

The island’s star attraction, though, is Dean’s Blue Hole, one of the world’s deepest blue holes, plunging 663 feet (202 m) into the ocean just off a white-sand beach.

Aerial view of Dean’s Blue Hole next to a white-sand beach on Long Island, the Bahamas
Dean’s Blue Hole drops 663 feet (202 m) just steps from a white-sand beach on Long Island.

Makers Air flies direct from Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport to Stella Maris on Long Island. At the time of writing, though, its booking calendar shows no departures during Thanksgiving week itself (Monday, November 23, to Saturday, November 28). The only bookable flights are on the Sundays either side, November 22 and November 29. Another common route is to fly to Nassau, then take a domestic “hopper” flight to Long Island.

6. Cat Island: Hike to the highest point in the Bahamas

Best for: Nature lovers and travelers who prefer culture over resort life.

Cat Island offers a mix of untouched natural beauty and authentic Bahamian culture, far from the crowds and big-resort feel of the touristy islands.

Its standout attraction is Mount Alvernia. Rising 206 feet (63 m) above sea level, it’s the country’s highest point, but it’s a short, relatively easy hike. At the top of the hill, you’ll find The Hermitage, a 1939 stone monastery.

The Hermitage stone monastery on top of Mount Alvernia on Cat Island, the Bahamas
The Hermitage, a small stone monastery built in 1939, sits at the top of Mount Alvernia on Cat Island.

Cat Island is the birthplace of Rake ‘n’ Scrape, so it has a strong traditional music scene. It’s also where legendary actor Sidney Poitier grew up, and you can visit his childhood home just outside of Arthur’s Town.

The most direct route from the US is via Makers Air. It flies from Fort Lauderdale Executive Airport to New Bight on Cat Island, but seats are limited during Thanksgiving week, with only a few departures still bookable at the time of writing. Otherwise, you can fly to Nassau and then take a short connecting flight.

7. Bimini: The Out Island you can reach in 25 minutes

Best for: Day trippers and weekend travelers.

Located just 50 miles off Florida’s east coast, Bimini is one of the easiest Out Islands to reach for a short Thanksgiving break or even a day trip.

Tropic Ocean Airways operates a seaplane from Fort Lauderdale that takes just 25 minutes and lands right in North Bimini. American Airlines also flies from Miami to South Bimini on Mondays, Wednesdays, and Saturdays.

If you land on South Bimini, a short ferry ride takes you across to North Bimini. From there, boat trips head out so you can scuba dive the underwater stones, also called Bimini Road. This submerged linear rock formation is said to be linked to the lost city of Atlantis, though there is no scientific evidence to prove it. Back on land, the seashell-covered Dolphin House in Alice Town is worth a stop.

How to plan an Out Islands Thanksgiving

Once you’ve decided which island to visit, follow these steps to keep your Thanksgiving trip smooth and stress-free.

  • Check the weather before you book: Late November is generally a good time to visit the Bahamas, with daytime highs of around 81°F (27°C) and nighttime lows of around 70°F (21°C). Hurricane season officially runs through the end of November, so some showers are possible, but they’re typically short and clear up quickly.
  • Book regional flights directly: Smaller airlines serving the Out Islands don’t always show up on major flight comparison sites, so book on the airlines’ own websites. If you’re connecting through Nassau, allow at least 1.5 hours to clear immigration and customs before your connecting flight.
  • Choose your travel dates strategically: Thanksgiving is typically an expensive travel period, but you can avoid the worst of the inflated rates by flying on particular days. Hopper’s 2026 data identifies Monday, November 23, as the cheapest day to depart, while Sunday, November 29, is one of the most expensive days of the year to fly.
  • Get your entry documents ready: US travelers need a passport that’s valid for at least six months when they arrive. You must also complete an immigration form on arrival.
  • Pack light: If you’re island hopping, check the luggage limits for the small planes and island ferries you will use. You may have less allowance than you expect, so plan your Bahamas packing list accordingly.
  • Don’t forget mobile data: Wi-Fi and mobile coverage can be patchy on the smaller, more remote islands. You can sort your data before you land with an eSIM, or buy a Bahamian SIM card when you arrive.

Stay connected on the Out Islands with Holafly

Island hopping in the Bahamas means small planes, ferries, and a lot of “wait, which dock is it?” moments. With an eSIM for the Bahamas from Holafly, you get unlimited data, 5G speeds where available, and 24/7 customer support. That way you can check ferry times, find your rental car, and share that empty pink beach the moment you see it. Install it before you fly and it switches on when you land.

What’s more, every Holafly eSIM includes Always On, 1 GB of monthly backup data at no additional cost. It stays active as long as the eSIM is installed, renews every month, and works in 150+ destinations. So if your plan runs out on the last day, or a spontaneous detour to one more cay stretches the trip, Always On keeps you connected for the trip home.

Plans that may interest you

Michaela Park

Michaela Park

Travel & Events Writer

Hi, I'm Mika, a South Korean writer living in the US. I cover travel and live events, focusing on the practical stuff that makes your trip smoother, whether you're navigating a new city or heading to a major international event.I'm also the founder of Search SEOul, South Korea's leading SEO conference, bringing together search marketing experts and speakers from around the world.

Read full bio